Ending Poverty for People with Disability – an appropriate use of Disability Employment Services
42% of those on Disability Support Pension live below the poverty line – in Australia 827,000 people receive the DSP – Therefore 347,340 people who have a disability live in poverty – about 1 person in 60.
What to do?
Raising the pension is an obvious answer but the truth is that we simply can’t afford that Australia has a shrinking tax base and as we are all getting older creating a burgeoning pension cost.
That doesn't mean nothing can be done. Just as pensioners are being required to self-fund more and more of their retirement so it makes sense for people who have a disability to be asked to share (wherever possible) a fairer share of their own financial needs.
The great news is that many want to, and many can. In fact, many people that receive the Disability Support Pension have chosen to either enter or re-enter the workforce and take up full time work, ending any requirement for welfare.
Why don’t more people do so?
It is my belief that under the present funding and contractual requirements for services supposedly set up to achieve just this outcome; some perverse disincentives have been created that actually act against this desirable progression.
Here is a simple example:
Each employment ‘outcome’ attracts a rewards from the funding body.
The financial reward is set at 2 levels and each placement effects the performance management tool used to indicate quality – “Star Ratings”
Individual employment and program survival is linked to performance in the Star Ratings.
No distinction is made between levels of employment and, for a person in receipt of the DSP, both financial and Star Rating reward is identical for an 8 or a 38 hour a week employment ‘outcome’.
Therefore a 40 hour a week position (this for my simple math mind) could be broken down to 5 x 8 hours a week and the service provider could, should they so wish lower the risks associated with job loss (negative in the Star Ratings), receive 5 times the financial reward and 5 times the positive effect of the Star Rating simply by breaking up a job.
In fact, assuming the highest funding level, the service provider could, by way of employment subsidy (which would itself be further supplemented by the Commonwealth) completely cover the cost of employment to the nominal employer and, at a rate of say $20ph, end up about $100k in the black at the end of 12 months. Repeat that over and over and not only could you make (and export) a lot of taxpayers’ money you would receive very favourable Star Ratings.
When I first pointed this out (I think towards the end of 2005) I was told, “I think we can rely upon the integrity of service providers” – well you might have been able to but 46 such providers went under in the last business allocation, victims of their own dedication to their clients and our community.
That is threatened again and in what is the most reprehensible travesty absolutely nothing has been done to effectively end malpractice and more importantly, orient programs toward ending poverty through the maximum use of the employability of people with disability.
The fact is that this approach may lower the participation rate (I suspect it won’t by much, because services will be genuinely encouraged to better engage with employers and the labour market) but the trade off will be significant reduction in the cost of benefit.
Keep the “Star Ratings” but tie them to dollars earned, hours worked, and time in employment.
Do that and watch the poverty numbers improve.
Seemingly complex problems don’t always need complex solutions.
Want to know more? – Skype me,
Want to make a change? – get in touch with your political representatives and tell them that for poverty to be addressed there must be change while some talent still remains from what was once a world class disability employment service.
Would you like a face-to-face meeting with Martin via Skype? Click the button below to make an appointment
Subscribe to this Blog - blog.novaemployment.com.au Copy the link above and paste it into your favourite Reader to subscribe to an RSS feed of this blog. To watch a short video explanation of RSS and how it helps you save time reading the web click here
Your Comments There are currently no comments on this article
On a Brighter Note On a brighter note....
No more about funding bodies (at least not this week)
On a MUCH brighter note NOVA's simply fabby film competition, Focusonability VI is generating some really significant interest with our web traffic measuring increases of many times last years viewers....
Utter Nonsense Utter Nonsense
Mismanagement at the highest level seems destined to continue despite a change in name for the people that hand out money to disability employment programs....
On a roll
We have a special campaign going in the St George and Sutherland Shires – we are trying to find 100 unemployed people who all have a disability some meaningful work....
Today marks the start of our first major advertising campaign for 2014.
We will have advertisements for the ability of our job seekers on just about every Sydney radio station, on Television, in railway stations and on motorway billboards, we’ll have many advertisements in local newspapers, distribute more than 1m flyers – in fact, we will advertise through pretty much every mass marketing medium you can think of....
The Need for Reform
The need for reform
Taken from: http://www.probonoaustralia.com.au/news/2014/01/disability-peak-bodies-meet-welfare-reviewer
“The employment services system in Australia that is supposed to focus on getting people with disability into work is broken....
The worst disability
I was asked what’s the hardest disability to overcome when it comes to finding work for people with disability?
Here’s my answer; There’s one disability that in almost 30 years we have never been able to beat – doesn’t matter how it’s wrapped, how we might present it, what sort of polish we give or even how much of a subsidy we attach; there’s one disability we can’t overcome....
Happy New Year!
Welcome back everyone!
Hope that you and yours had a fabulous break and that you, like me, are excited about the challenges and opportunities of 2014....
Taken from: http://www.abc.net.au/news/2013-12-23/government-defends-plans-to-alter-disability-support-pension/5171914 23.12.13 (09.00)
Kevin Andrews defends plan to alter Disability Support Pension entitlements
The Government has defended plans to alter the Disability Support Pension to make it harder for some people to receive it permanently....
NDIS Ticking.... Time Bomb
In this blog about 20 months ago I wrote:
It was my pleasure to have lunch with Senator Marise Payne and the Hon Member for Mackellar, Bronwyn Bishop on Monday....
Best Day The Cube at Campbelltown was the (excellent) venue for today's Transition to Work (TTW) graduation ceremony as the class of 2013 met for the last time....
Aurora TV this Sunday
8.30pm Sunday December 1st 2013.
Cancel all appointments, get a pizza and a cold beer (teetotallers substitute whatever floats boat).
This Sunday see the kick-off of Aurora TV's coverage of the FocusonAbility 2013 film competition....
Currently studying Community Services and left us a message over the weekend - no contact details
Have another go!...
Crossing the road
In a couple of weeks time I will be speaking at a graduation ceremony for approximately 80 young men and women who, through the NSW State Government’s Transition to Work Program, have made the move from trainee to taxpayer....
26 years ago I became involved in finding work for people with disability. That time has taught me some important truths and it is little short of a tragedy that others on the same journey haven’t read the signs....
Latest "Stars" Regular readers will know that I am a hater of the Commonwealths performance measurement tool for Disability Employment Services – The ‘Star’ Ratings – a silly and misleading name that in the last purchasing round led to the loss of careers, skills, resources and confidence....
I have received questions from around the world as to our present status given the enormous bushfire's presently threatening Sydney and the Blue Mountains....
This is Brilliant!
This is brilliant (cut and paste): http://www.disney.com.au/lionkingautismfriendly/
Well done Autism Awareness on seeing and filling a need. Do everyone a favour and post forward to your networks, the show needs to sell out and we need to show the need for similar and more....
Creaming and Parking
Apparently, Gaming behaviour (using loopholes in the contract for disability employment services) doesn't happen in Australia and our last contract for business wasn't in any way influenced by such behaviour....
September September's results
Millwall 2 Leeds 0 (Yes, I stayed up and watched the game live - there was something for everyone, unless you support Leeds!)
September has been a great month for the team at NOVA with a large number of new job starts, really fabulous outcomes with many Traineeships and Apprenticeships and some remarkable efforts from some job seekers to overcome very real obstacles to their employment - well done to all....
Hobby Horse Attended the Penrith small business awards on Wednesday night and, apart from meeting several old friends and many acquaintances I was reminded of the right reasons for hiring a person with a disability....