How to rort* the Star Ratings I.
Somewhere between 4 and 5 years ago I attended a then Department of Employment and Workplace Relations (DEWR now DEEWR) seminar on what was to the proposed measurement system for Disability Employment Services.
What was eventually created came to be called "star ratings' a sliding scale from 1 (poor perfromance) to 5 (good performance).
Disability Employment Services should be performance measured and the results should be publicly available.
However, there was an obvious and howling error in their proposed measurement plan. Every job counted as ‘1’. In other words an 8 hour a week job counted and was remunerated exactly the same as a full time position.
I pointed out that this was likely to encourage (under pressure) services to take short cuts and seek part time work/job carving - that’s where you take a full time job and break it into several smaller part time roles.
DEWR were adamant that this wouldn't’t happen.
For two reasons:
1: ‘Service providers wouldn't’t do that’ &
2: DEWR would ‘put systems into place that would prevent abuse’ (I wrote that down very carefully).
Well guess what?
Both sides came to be under pressure; service providers to get results and DEWR to have a program that generated outcomes. This was, and is, a recipe for disaster - not for either of the above - but for the independence and opportunities available to people with a disability.
Instead of fewer full time positions you’d get lots of part time ones.
Exactly what’s happened.
And, I can prove it.
There are main indicators for measuring performance under the Star Rating system: number of placements, hours worked, wages paid and jobs retained. Each are assigned a weighting. The results achieved by a program are then presented as a percentage against local and national results.
I recently met with 2 other Campbelltown (south west Sydney) service providers. We all had higher than average (by as much as 30%) hours worked and wages earned, retention was as good or better than average. However all programs ‘scored’ lower Star Ratings than competing programs.
You don’t need to be a genius to work out why – not as many placements.
So, is this where we’ve failed, we simply didn’t find enough opportunities?
No, what happened was the thing that DEEWR encourage service providers to do (and yes, I have heaps of witnesses who will swear under oath), jobs found have been carved up.
That’s how you have higher wages and hours worked.
Here’s how to rort the Star Ratings (I, and yes there is going to be II):
Encourage staff to only seek part time positions: they are easier to find and the hours required to provide post placement support shrink significantly for the same financial reward to the service provider + improved Star Ratings..
When a full time position is offered encourage the employer to split the role into 2, 3 or 4 positions, you can tell the employing company that they are doing a great thing giving more opportunities to more people.
What happens?
DEEWR get better statistical numbers and are able to say X number of jobs have been found
Service providers receive additional income for extra placements
Service Star Ratings jump as more number are recorded in the highest scoring category: number of jobs found.
However, people who have a disability and want to work full time because that's what most folk want/have to do and they would like to earn as much as possible please are at a disadvantage.
You get what you measure. Measure the wrong things and you can twist ‘performance in a very unhealthy direction.
What to do?
We have a new government and a new Minister. Mr O’Connor seemed a thoroughly decent man and Senator Arbib presents as a bloke who will listen.
On Friday the Minister wrote to all service providers (in part):
“ I have asked the Department to establish an Industry Reference Group to contribute to the development of a new performance framework for the new programs. Membership of this group will initially include peak industry associations – ACE, NESA, NDS, Jobs Australia, the Australia Rehabilitation Providers’ Association and the Australian Federation of Disability Organisations”.
Minister, well done. And now, recognising that the Star Ratings are/were a deeply flawed instrument to measure disability employment services performance could you please state unambiguously your intention not to use them in the awarding of future contracts?
* I said 'rort' at the start - maybe that's a tad harsh, how about 'manipulate to advantage'?
Would you like a face-to-face meeting with Martin via Skype? Click the button below to make an appointment
Subscribe to this Blog - blog.novaemployment.com.au Copy the link above and paste it into your favourite Reader to subscribe to an RSS feed of this blog. To watch a short video explanation of RSS and how it helps you save time reading the web click here
Your Comments There are currently no comments on this article
Previous Posts
New Contract but no change!
New Contract but no change!
Today marks the first day of a new Disability Employment Service (DES) contract.
There are new players and new rules....
Administrative Overload
'It's nice to be busy' and 'busy is better than idle' and all of my mum's other sayings about work being good for you, and all of them said; we're drowning!
The administrative burden of a new Disability Employment Service contract (starts July 1st) and the mountains of paperwork required for an NDIS dollar (approximately 10X that of the former TTW program) has seen us add 3 extra staff to the admin team and we are still receiving a large volume of enquiries that are causing us some time delay in getting back to folk....
Podcasts I've been learning all about Podcasts (I suspect that this may be a long road!)
However, getting paid to be inspired is not the worst way to spend a Monday afternoon and that is just how my day has gone....
Lucky Lucky
I am truly fortunate to work with the very best people in this great nation and we are truly lucky to be part of the best short film festival this side of anywhere!
"Focusonability" voting starts today and there is an even larger number of films (287) than last year....
On the money Sometime over the next week a new Disability Employment Service contract will be announced.
We are moving into a new world of greater consumer choice and greater mobility of job seekers....
Making a tough job tougher!
Making a tough job tougher
It isnt easy to get a decent job and its harder to do so if you have a disability.
NOVA employs around 190 people, an effective and experienced team who are able to draw upon a staff of highly skilled trainers and a support program honed over almost 30 years and tens of thousands of participants....
Your Work There was never any doubt in my mind that I would work. My dad told me I would work and there wasn't ever a suggestion that my future held an alternative option....
Not so bad! Taken from: Today's Guardian at 4.09pm Tuesday 7th November 2017:
www.theguardian.com/global-development-professionals-network/2016/jun/23/russia-and-the-us-have-the-worst-employment-gaps-for-disabled-people
In a world full of discouragement there’s always a space for good news....
Informed Choice
The NDIS mantra is 'choice and control'
To be valuable, choice needs to be informed.
Since 2010:
Average Sydney Disability Employment Services placement rates are 34....
Hard Job
It's voting time at "Focusonability" - with a record number of films entered, a tremendous effort by more than 100 High Schools and 19 countries competing in the International section it was always going to be a hard job to pick a winner....
Choice & Control
The NDIS slogans around choice and control demonstrate the importance of consumer involvement in both the choice and control of supports they need.
However, in order to be valuable, choice needs to be informed by accurate data such is this: http://www....
Belfast
Last week (14-16) it was my privilege to attend the 1st World Supported Employment Conference in Belfast, Northern Ireland.
"Employment for All - A Global Perspective" brought workers from around the globe (primarily Europe) to discuss best practice in supported employment....
Quality and the Stars Quality and the Stars
There have probably been few people more openly critical of the Disability Employment Service (DES) Star Ratings than me.
The Stars, ranging from 1 to 5 are supposed to give some insight into whether a service is a poor or high performing program....
DEA Forum
Attended the Disability Employment Australia (DEA) forum in Canberra. THis is a regular get together that offers disability employment services tha chance to be kept up to date from our funding body and also listed to expert speakers on topics associated with the goal of seeing as many people as possible find and keep suitable employment....
Greatest Asset
NOVAs greatest asset is its staff. I suspect you would struggle to find the CEO of any organisation state their staff are not vital and at the core of business reputation and results....
A corner turned?
We are presently holding events to promote employment for people with disability - nor surprise there, that's our job.
What has been a surprise is the willingness of employers to come along and listen and more importantly, to consider adopting inclusive employment practices across their organisations....
Say No to Quotas!
The pernicious idea that 'quota's' might be the solution for disability employment continue:
http://www.canberratimes.com.au/comment/how-china-trumps-australia-when-it-comes-to-supporting-disabled-workers-20170103-gtl7bh....
Percentages
Faced with the daunting task of improving the number of employment outcomes with out sacrificing the quality of service delivered to people with disability how have we fared (sort of Year in Review II)?
The number of placements made has seriously improved - up 31% in 2015 and a further 14% in 2016, NOVA operates at at rate of placement better than 150% over 2014!
Whats really exciting is that this has been achieved without compromising on the level of disability that can be supported by NOVA's teams (if anything this has risen)....
Famous last words!
O.K. - sorry that you need to cut and paste: http://www.smh.com.au/business/workplace-relations/100-million-payday-for-1anhour-staff-with-disabilities-20161216-gtcius....
Last Post
Not sure if this will be my last blog post for 2016 but just in case, a quick look back at 2016:
Best ever year for total number of placements
Best ever year for long term employment outcomes
Best ever year for Apprenticeships and Traineeships
Best ever year for Transition to Work outcomes
Best ever year for media coverage
Best ever year for 'Focusonability'
Best ever year for Transition to Work (TTW)
How about 2017?
Looking good, so stay in touch and have a terrific holiday, be safe and hopefully Santa will bring you all that you wish for....
Subscribe to this Blog