How to rort* the Star Ratings I.
Somewhere between 4 and 5 years ago I attended a then Department of Employment and Workplace Relations (DEWR now DEEWR) seminar on what was to the proposed measurement system for Disability Employment Services.
What was eventually created came to be called "star ratings' a sliding scale from 1 (poor perfromance) to 5 (good performance).
Disability Employment Services should be performance measured and the results should be publicly available.
However, there was an obvious and howling error in their proposed measurement plan. Every job counted as ‘1’. In other words an 8 hour a week job counted and was remunerated exactly the same as a full time position.
I pointed out that this was likely to encourage (under pressure) services to take short cuts and seek part time work/job carving - that’s where you take a full time job and break it into several smaller part time roles.
DEWR were adamant that this wouldn't’t happen.
For two reasons:
1: ‘Service providers wouldn't’t do that’ &
2: DEWR would ‘put systems into place that would prevent abuse’ (I wrote that down very carefully).
Well guess what?
Both sides came to be under pressure; service providers to get results and DEWR to have a program that generated outcomes. This was, and is, a recipe for disaster - not for either of the above - but for the independence and opportunities available to people with a disability.
Instead of fewer full time positions you’d get lots of part time ones.
Exactly what’s happened.
And, I can prove it.
There are main indicators for measuring performance under the Star Rating system: number of placements, hours worked, wages paid and jobs retained. Each are assigned a weighting. The results achieved by a program are then presented as a percentage against local and national results.
I recently met with 2 other Campbelltown (south west Sydney) service providers. We all had higher than average (by as much as 30%) hours worked and wages earned, retention was as good or better than average. However all programs ‘scored’ lower Star Ratings than competing programs.
You don’t need to be a genius to work out why – not as many placements.
So, is this where we’ve failed, we simply didn’t find enough opportunities?
No, what happened was the thing that DEEWR encourage service providers to do (and yes, I have heaps of witnesses who will swear under oath), jobs found have been carved up.
That’s how you have higher wages and hours worked.
Here’s how to rort the Star Ratings (I, and yes there is going to be II):
Encourage staff to only seek part time positions: they are easier to find and the hours required to provide post placement support shrink significantly for the same financial reward to the service provider + improved Star Ratings..
When a full time position is offered encourage the employer to split the role into 2, 3 or 4 positions, you can tell the employing company that they are doing a great thing giving more opportunities to more people.
What happens?
DEEWR get better statistical numbers and are able to say X number of jobs have been found
Service providers receive additional income for extra placements
Service Star Ratings jump as more number are recorded in the highest scoring category: number of jobs found.
However, people who have a disability and want to work full time because that's what most folk want/have to do and they would like to earn as much as possible please are at a disadvantage.
You get what you measure. Measure the wrong things and you can twist ‘performance in a very unhealthy direction.
What to do?
We have a new government and a new Minister. Mr O’Connor seemed a thoroughly decent man and Senator Arbib presents as a bloke who will listen.
On Friday the Minister wrote to all service providers (in part):
“ I have asked the Department to establish an Industry Reference Group to contribute to the development of a new performance framework for the new programs. Membership of this group will initially include peak industry associations – ACE, NESA, NDS, Jobs Australia, the Australia Rehabilitation Providers’ Association and the Australian Federation of Disability Organisations”.
Minister, well done. And now, recognising that the Star Ratings are/were a deeply flawed instrument to measure disability employment services performance could you please state unambiguously your intention not to use them in the awarding of future contracts?
* I said 'rort' at the start - maybe that's a tad harsh, how about 'manipulate to advantage'?
Would you like a face-to-face meeting with Martin via Skype? Click the button below to make an appointment
Subscribe to this Blog - blog.novaemployment.com.au Copy the link above and paste it into your favourite Reader to subscribe to an RSS feed of this blog. To watch a short video explanation of RSS and how it helps you save time reading the web click here
Your Comments There are currently no comments on this article
Previous Posts
Good Result!
Received the following yesterday morning:
Hi Nova, just wanted to give my feedback in regards to my mother getting a job through you guys and the amazing impact it has had!! The job that mum has received has changed her outlook on everything! She is now much more confident in her self and her abilities....
Welfare Benefits and Health
It is said that power corrupts, but actually it's truer that power attracts the corruptible. The sane are usually attracted by other things than power: David Brin
DES providers don't need nor should they have been given the authority to suspend welfare benefits (see above)....
Disgusting!
Disgusting!: https://probonoaustralia.com.au/news/2019/07/ndis-data-drop-reveals-severe-employment-gaps/
I have spoken previously on, to quote former President Bush, 'the soft bigotry of low expectations' - if you are a member of a marginalised group the public don't expect much and are surprised when anything much is achieved!
I've been in this game for more than 30 years and have been privileged to see literally thousands of terrific men and women leave NOVA To gain (and retain) great jobs....
Goodness me!
Goodness me!
Read this article: https://www.smh.com.au/national/no-lights-no-linen-how-alex-survived-for-six-years-on-newstart-20190717-p5284q....
Changing Attitudes
One of the hardest things to do is change a person's attitude - if they are favourably disposed to you, all's well and good - if someone holds a contrary view it's an uphill battle to change a mindset....
Retention Retention, Retention!
Just when you thought things couldn't get any better, something comes along that causes you to stop and to reconsider the way your business is conducted....
Properly Caring
Much is made about the easy life enjoyed by people on welfare - we've all seen the 'news' items that show flagrant abuse of the system with welfare recipients engaged in employment or other activities that conflict with the obligation to inform Centrelink of change in status or simply as a means of defrauding the Commonwealth....
2 Things
2 Things:
First:
About the middle of February I wrote: i. "NOVA Needs You!
We are presently engaged in a very significant recruitment drive and are particularly keen to hear from folk with disability and/or sales experience to join our team of Employment Consultants - THIS IS NOT AN EASY JOB - you need to be resilient, self sacrificing and have stacks of smarts and even then we only take the best....
We're struggling!
NOVA Needs You!
We are presently engaged in a very significant recruitment drive and are particularly keen to hear from folk with disability and/or sales experience to join our team of Employment Consultants - THIS IS NOT AN EASY JOB - you need to be resilient, self sacrificing and have stacks of smarts and even then we only take the best....
Extraordinary Results
When Government Star Ratings seem designed to celebrate the ordinary, it is a pleasure to be able to share a terrific piece of selfless effort on behalf of others....
Whats wrong with Employment Services II? What's wrong with Employment Services II
My mum used to frequently admonish my brothers and I with the words, 'if at first you don't succeed, try, try again'....
Whats wrong with Employment Services? There's rumours of a shake-up in the Job Active program - word is, the program isn't making a real difference and employers don't like it!
There's plenty of evidence to suggest that, despite the best intent of Government and funding body, the Disability Employment Service (DES) is similarly in the doldrums....
I need you! Comrades
NOVA needs you - we are very keen to enlist new members of our organisation.
Here's what you need: the patience of Job, the strength of the Hulk, the wisdom of Solomon and a selfless devotion caring for the needs of others worthy of Mother Teresa....
Tragic Loss People with Disability lost a true champion last Wednesday with the unexpected passing of a truly great man, the Chief Executive Officer of Inclusion Australia and a dear friend Mr Paul Cain....
Fair Warning
I'm giving fair warning of my intention to expose examples of the current DES-ESS contract's exploitation.
I have written to the Commonwealth expressing my concerns about clear manipulation of the present contract....
Fundamentals
The new contract for Disability Employment Services (DES) will not bring performance improvement.
Government will scratch it's head, blame the economy, blame people with disability, talk about educating employers and spend money on consultations before coming to the conclusion that people with disability must meet more stringent 'mutual obligations'....
100%
Each year, around about the International Day of People with a Disability (IDPwD) NOVA Employment holds a formal graduation for students that have participated in our pre-employment programs....
Profiting from poverty
Profiting from Poverty
I am genuinely horrified by this disaster: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/jul/02/the-demerit-system-is-ruthless-social-policy-designed-to-keep-the-poor-powerless
I believe that we presently represent the job hopes of around 1500 people, in various stages of their progression to independent employment....
New Contract but no change!
New Contract but no change!
Today marks the first day of a new Disability Employment Service (DES) contract.
There are new players and new rules....
Administrative Overload
'It's nice to be busy' and 'busy is better than idle' and all of my mum's other sayings about work being good for you, and all of them said; we're drowning!
The administrative burden of a new Disability Employment Service contract (starts July 1st) and the mountains of paperwork required for an NDIS dollar (approximately 10X that of the former TTW program) has seen us add 3 extra staff to the admin team and we are still receiving a large volume of enquiries that are causing us some time delay in getting back to folk....
Subscribe to this Blog